SCUGSoul Coughing Underground

Chapter 5 · 1997 to 1998

El Oso

The third album, released September 29, 1998, was the band's commercial high point and the most deliberately produced record they made. It reached No. 49 on the Billboard 200 and No. 69 in Canada, and "Circles" became their only real radio hit.1

Drum and Bass

Promo poster for El Oso: the four band members in grey jumpsuits, orange goggles and backpacks on a lawn at night, the El Oso bear logo below
The 1998 El Oso promo poster, from the jumpsuit shoot. Photo by Snorri Brothers.

The new sound came from the road. Before writing the record the band toured with Full Cycle DJs Krust and Die, and Doughty had spent about three months living in London in 1996, soaking up the drum and bass clubs (Vox reported it in July 1997). He joked to Billboard that whatever he was absorbing might come out sounding like Led Zeppelin's take on reggae. Gabay told the label that drum and bass "eventually snuck into my music." He pictures dancers when he writes beats, and with jungle people bend their knees while their heads bob up and down, so now he tries to get heads moving as well as hips. He told Gil Kaufman the week El Oso came out that he brought jungle beats to "Blame" and "The Incumbent" and went after more bass than the band had ever had, especially subsonic, shake-your-jaw bass, on songs like "I Miss the Girl" and "Misinformed."21

Bristol came to them in person in July 1997. At The Fleece, according to The Independent, Propellerheads had remixed the new single and the band had recently recorded with Roni Size and Reprazent. A rumored onstage mix-up with Size didn't happen, though he was in the crowd, and DJ Die and MC Dynamite ran the sound system before and after the set.3

Three Producers, Three Rooms

Credits split the record by track:

Producer Tracks Where
Tchad Blake with Soul Coughing "Rolling," "Misinformed," "Circles," "St. Louise Is Listening," "Maybe I'll Come Down," "Houston," "$300," "Monster Man," "Pensacola," "I Miss the Girl," "So Far I Have Not Found the Science" Sunset Sound Factory, Hollywood ("Science" also at Magic Hotel, Hollywood, and Looking Glass)
Optical (Metalheadz, Goldie, Grooverider) "Blame," "The Incumbent" The Looking Glass Studios, New York
Pat Dillett "Fully Retractable" The Looking Glass Studios, New York

The label bio says the Blake sessions ran about twelve weeks over the winter, and that Blake's room was again full of keyboards, whistles, bells, toys and odd speakers. Doughty said that for once they had to fully finish their songs, and they went wild with overdubs. Degli Antoni, who did the Pro Tools editing across much of the album, said he felt they had finally squeezed the press hard enough. Gabay praised Optical for running their parts through his filters without tampering with the music. He told Modern Drummer how the Optical tracks were built. For "The Incumbent" the band handed over fragments: a bit of beat from Gabay, a distorted bass sound from Steinberg, and a few sentences Doughty recited over and over. Optical sampled them and assembled the closer. On the other track he took eight or sixteen bars at a time, so it sounds like a live drummer.4 Blake's toys are all over it. On "Rolling," Gabay played toy bells, Doughty played toy piano and Blake played a shaker that, Gabay said, may have contained somebody's ashes. "So Far I Have Not Found the Science" combined a cheap four-track recording with a real studio sound, which they then made even stupider-sounding on purpose.2 The album was mastered by Bob Ludwig at Gateway Mastering in Portland, Maine. Steinberg gave his own account on Green Room Tales. Sessions ran twice at Blake's studio plus two weeks in New York, where they asked for another room full of toys. He said Blake is good with deadlines, with no starting too early and no 24-hour sessions that leave everyone too stupid to hear the song. He also said the songs came together in different ways: only about three came from loops, while "Misinformed," "Rolling" and "Monster Man" started with the drums, and "I Miss the Girl," "Maybe I'll Come Down" and "St. Louise Is Listening" had been played live for ages. The band had become more of a studio band, he said, thanks to writing movie songs on the fly, and they liked going in with a blank slate.

Doughty's Studio Diary

Black-and-white portrait of the four band members crouched close together and looking toward the camera, one in glasses, one in a baseball cap, one with cropped light hair, one with long dark hair
From the El Oso era.

The best firsthand account of the sessions is The El Oso Novella, which Doughty posted to the AOL music board on December 1, 1997, midway through the record under the title "The Making of El Oso."5 Its key points:

  • A new way of writing. At demos in San Francisco in June 1997, Gabay recorded families of beats he thought of as cells with endless variations. Doughty took the tape to Pensacola, looped the beats in his sampler and wrote melodies over them. Vox found him there in July 1997 holed up in a friend's cottage with no phone, where his label couldn't reach him. Stumbling out of a sports bar one night, he ran into a street protest by Christian fundamentalists with placards and a curse for the patrons, which he later called one of life's great moments.6 In Los Angeles he would lay the loop and his vocals to tape, Gabay would play variation after variation over it in the drum booth, the loop came out, and everyone piled parts on top. "Rolling," "Misinformed" and "Monster Man" started this way. Doughty noted that before, a song's tension usually lived between the words and a guitar part; now it lived between the words and the drums.
  • The junk pile. Blake's room at the Sound Factory held a decade of collected gear: pedals, odd amps and speakers, old keyboards and a trunk of toys. While Blake tweaked for an hour after a basic track, everyone else raided the pile, so takes came back covered in overdubs (an Ahuja-bullhorn harmony, celeste, chopped vocal samples, Hammond pedals), and rough mixes became a matter of hacking the underbrush back down to the song.
  • Hours and tools. Blake ran a strict noon-to-nine day, and Doughty said they averaged one song every two days. His main vocal mic was an AKG D112, normally a kick drum mic, which he joked might be why he didn't hate his own tone.
  • "Pensacola." It started at a Minneapolis soundcheck over a Steinberg bassline, which Doughty first sang in a Billy Bragg bellow. In the studio he slurred a low, whispery scratch take that he hated and asked to erase. He recut it in the bellow, the band built parts around that, and then Blake slyly brought the scratch vocal back in. Because the two takes didn't line up, everything sat slightly off-kilter, and that version stuck.
  • Trouble with "Maybe I'll Come Down." The band had learned to let it hang in big rooms live and couldn't get that onto tape; it kept sounding small and flat.
  • Guests and outtakes. Oakland rapper Casual of Hieroglyphics recorded verses on an unreleased song called "Needle to the Bar" and freestyled over "212," six totally different takes. Elliott Smith, in town scoring a Gus Van Sant film, sang a few songs into Blake's binaural dummy head for possible sampling and jammed on piano; Doughty said nothing had been done with those tapes yet. A collaboration with Roni Size, Die and Krust was planned for early 1998.
The four band members in matching jumpsuits
The jumpsuits, El Oso era. Photo by Snorri Brothers.
  • "Suzy Snowflake." For a Warner radio Christmas CD the band picked the 1950s novelty from their publisher's catalog (after "What Do You Get a Wookiee for Christmas" proved unreadable) and spent a full day overdubbing it with a straight face: Blake on bells, degli Antoni on celeste, Gabay on sleigh bells and reciting the lyrics in Hebrew, Steinberg on plastic pan pipe.
  • Band lore. Doughty's "gangadank," his hip-hop-derived acoustic strum on "Is Chicago, Is Not Chicago," "Moon Sammy" and "The Idiot Kings," came with band superstitions, including never two in a row in a set. El Oso had none, which reportedly broke Gus Brandt's heart, since the live favorite "Parking Lot" (played live as "Don't Go Wreck the Car") was started in the studio but never finished or released. Degli Antoni called the long jammy tails of songs "lumber" to be cut out. A&R man Randall Davis Kaye dropped in for dinner every other night, and he skipped the usual label talk of bridges and hooks. His running line was that he just wanted the band to buy him a house, so when he heard the keeper of "St. Louise Is Listening" at full volume and announced he was picturing a front porch, it was the house he had in mind.
  • The hotel. The band stayed at a magician-themed hotel behind the Chinese Theatre, which explains the "Magic Hotel" credit on "So Far I Have Not Found the Science."

Doughty's diary counts six weeks of recording before they came back in January 1998 to mix. The label's bio says twelve weeks, which counts the mixing too.

The Sequence Tapes

Soul Coughing band photo from the El Oso era
Around the time of El Oso.

Five sequence DATs from the first half of 1998 show the album taking shape. The February and March tapes hold a different El Oso: "Jiggaboo" (which later turned up on degli Antoni's Horse Tricks), "These Are the Reasons" and "16 Horses" are on it, and "Blame," "Fully Retractable" and "The Incumbent" aren't there yet. The March tape runs 51:06; Warner dubbed it to a CrO2 cassette eight days later for internal use. By June three new songs were in, three were out, and "212," still called "Minneapolis," was closing the record, until "The Incumbent" took its spot two weeks later. Only "Rolling" and "Misinformed" never moved.

A few titles changed before release:

  • "Minneapolis" → "212"
  • "Theme" / "Love Theme from Misinformed" → "Adolpha Zantziger" (B-side on the "Circles" promo 7-inch)
  • "Jiggaboo" → never released on the album; degli Antoni later put it on Horse Tricks

Bold: new on that tape. Point at or tap a song to follow it across the tapes.

Feb. 16

Album Sequence #2, February 16, 1998

Sequenced at Sunset Sound Factory in Los Angeles. Fifteen songs make the album, with six more under a line at the bottom.

  1. Rolling
  2. Misinformed
  3. St. Louise Is Listening
  4. So Far I Have Not Found the Science
  5. Maybe I'll Come Down
  6. Jiggaboo
  7. I Miss the Girl
  8. These Are the Reasons
  9. 16 Horses
  10. $300
  11. Pensacola
  12. 212
  13. Houston
  14. Circles
  15. Monster Man

Below the line / Non-album tracks

  • That's a Strange Thing
  • Rare Star Ball
  • F-Train
  • Needle to the Bar
  • Love Theme from Misinformed
  • The Whole World

Mar. 31

Original Master, March 31, 1998

A finished 14-song album, copied to its own production master that runs 51:06. "212" is gone and "Circles" jumps to fourth. The extras are nearly the same as February's.

In: nothing. Out: "212".

  1. Rolling
  2. Misinformed
  3. St. Louise Is Listening
  4. Circles
  5. Maybe I'll Come Down
  6. Jiggaboo
  7. I Miss the Girl
  8. These Are the Reasons
  9. 16 Horses
  10. $300
  11. Pensacola
  12. Houston
  13. So Far I Have Not Found the Science
  14. Monster Man

Below the line / Non-album tracks

  • That's a Strange Thing
  • Rare Star Ball
  • F-Train
  • Needle to the Bar
  • Theme
  • The Whole World

June 1

June 1, 1998 Sequence

Thirteen songs. Three new ones are in, three are out, "Maybe I'll Come Down" is missing, and "212," under its early title "Minneapolis," is back as the closer.

In: "Fully Retractable", "Blame", "212". Out: "Maybe I'll Come Down", "Jiggaboo", "These Are the Reasons", "16 Horses".

  1. Rolling
  2. Misinformed
  3. Circles
  4. $300
  5. I Miss the Girl
  6. Pensacola
  7. Fully Retractable
  8. Monster Man
  9. Houston
  10. St. Louise Is Listening
  11. So Far I Have Not Found the Science
  12. Blame
  13. Minneapolis

June 15

Album Tracks Temp Sequence, June 15, 1998

The final 14 songs, in a different order. "Maybe I'll Come Down" is back and "The Incumbent" takes the closing slot from "212."

In: "Maybe I'll Come Down", "The Incumbent". Out: "212".

  1. Rolling
  2. Misinformed
  3. Circles
  4. $300
  5. Blame
  6. Maybe I'll Come Down
  7. St. Louise Is Listening
  8. Houston
  9. Monster Man
  10. Fully Retractable
  11. Pensacola
  12. I Miss the Girl
  13. So Far I Have Not Found the Science
  14. The Incumbent

July 17

Final Master #4, July 17, 1998

The released running order, 56:54. The matching EQ reference lists "Rolling" as the version "with audible compression."

In: nothing. Out: nothing.

  1. Rolling
  2. Misinformed
  3. Circles
  4. Blame
  5. St. Louise Is Listening
  6. Maybe I'll Come Down
  7. Houston
  8. $300
  9. Fully Retractable
  10. Monster Man
  11. Pensacola
  12. I Miss the Girl
  13. So Far I Have Not Found the Science
  14. The Incumbent

Song Notes

  • "$300" grew out of a backmasked Chris Rock bit from Roll with the New. Doughty sampled it into his Ensoniq ASR-10 just to hear it forward, then built the song around what he found.
  • "Circles" came from a confusing breakup, Doughty said, and the chorus says so plainly.
  • "Pensacola" carries lyrics by Ava Chin, and degli Antoni wrote the words to "The Incumbent." On M2 in January 1999 the host teased Doughty that one El Oso lyric swore off New York even though he was by then back living there. Gabay said he had warned Doughty not to spit in the well he was drinking from, that recording the song would send him back to New York, and compared it to tattooing a girlfriend's name on yourself.
  • Doughty later singled out "So Far I Have Not Found the Science" as the one song on the album substantially co-written with degli Antoni.
  • Japanese editions added "212" and "Rare Star Ball."

Degli Antoni added a few notes of his own in 2000. "The Incumbent" fused two separate songs, the original "Incumbent" and "New York, I Won't Go Back," which he said were like magnets that had to be stuck together. He named "Maybe I'll Come Down" the hardest song they ever recorded, with nobody quite sure why. And "Don't Go Wreck the Car," he agreed, was a great song that just never worked as a recording.

The Bear

Painted sign for El Oso Bar & Restaurant with the California flag bear, advertising food from Spain, tapas, steaks, seafood and paella
Degli Antoni's photo of the El Oso Bar & Restaurant sign in San Francisco, California flag bear and all.

The title came from the set-list bears. The label bio teased that California's state flag might have helped, and Doughty would only say that the bear wants honey. The cover creature, a sort of monkey-bear, was drawn by cartoonist Jim Woodring, creator of Frank. The idea grew from a photo degli Antoni took.7 The photo's subject was real: El Oso Bar & Restaurant in San Francisco, degli Antoni's hometown, a Spanish place whose sign put the California flag bear under the name. Degli Antoni has called it part of the inspiration for the album. The restaurant now operates as El Valenciano. The bear later became a fan symbol, showing up on billboards for the 2024 reunion.

Singles and Reception

"Circles" peaked at No. 8 on Billboard's Alternative chart, No. 38 on Mainstream Rock and No. 24 on Bubbling Under. Chris Applebaum directed the video. Doughty talked about the shoot on MTV's M2 in January 1999, with Jancee Dunn: the tunnel was built from scratch at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, painted the wrong color and repainted, and the wardrobe department had about 60 red sweaters, including versions with no neck or no sleeves for each stage of the unraveling. Video shoots, he said, always run on "just five more minutes." Gabay said he walked away with the Prada suit. Cartoon Network built a Groovies spot around it with Hanna-Barbera characters walking past the same looping background. "St. Louise Is Listening" followed in 1998 and "Rolling" in 1999, the latter with a Betty Boop-synced video. Degli Antoni explained it on a Green Room Tales interview: former Warner Bros. Records executive Steven Baker loved the album so much that he and an editor went into the archives and cut a video from old cartoon footage, mostly black and white, cut to six or seven songs. There is no band footage in it, and he called it a parting gift. Cartoon Network aired it, and they said it was darker than it sounds. The "Circles" promo 7-inch, with two non-album B-sides, got its cover from a fan: Sharla Smith won Warner Bros.' "Design Our 7-inch Cover Art" contest, and the band posed with her and the framed winner.81

Single Year US Alternative Peak Video
"Circles" 1998 No. 8 Chris Applebaum
"St. Louise Is Listening" 1998 Did not chart None listed
"Rolling" 1999 Did not chart Steven Baker (Betty Boop-synced)

Reviews split. Christgau gave it an A-minus and Entertainment Weekly a B-plus, while Pitchfork (4.6) and Spin (5 of 10) were cool on it. Spin's Chuck Eddy, in the November 1998 issue, paired it with Cake's Prolonging the Magic (which got a 6), heard the grooves of "Monster Man" and "Houston" wearing thin, and found the record's closest brush with coherence in "The Incumbent." The Guardian's Caroline Sullivan gave it four stars and said the band deserved the sales it wasn't getting, singling out Doughty's flailing hysteria on "Monster Man."9 The Washington Post's Mark Jenkins said Soul Coughing had given drum 'n' bass form and voice, and heard Doughty howl "like Allen Ginsberg riding a clattering locomotive."10 Over time, fan opinion has tilted toward El Oso as the band's most fully realized album.1112

Album Week

Spin's October 1998 issue caught Doughty at the Knitting Factory, reading from Slinky in the club's basement and telling the crowd to heckle him, "I mean it." Brendan Baber's "Brain Spotting" item called him an unlikely rock star and an overgrown army brat. Doughty quoted the New York Press calling him "eminently strangleable," and read his way down the El Oso track list calling the songs a drug song, a fame song and several kinds of love song. Steinberg said Warner's confidence in the band was becoming "more and more loaded," and Warner marketing vice president Peter Rauh said they were "primed to reach their biggest audience yet."

The four band members against a white brick wall with Sharla Smith, who holds a framed piece of cover art
Sharla Smith with the band and her winning design, a photo that ran on SCUG and the 5% Nation.

The newsgroup caught the rollout in real time. Warner's street team was screening a promo video that set six El Oso songs to old Warner Bros. cartoons, the same footage that became the tour's backdrop, and record stores showed it in-store; Borders in Westlake, Ohio, ran it in early October 1998. The vinyl edition came with a promo 7-inch whose bonus cuts one fan called "strange and different but worth a listen," in a sleeve designed by a fan who won a design-a-cover contest. In Los Angeles, two KCRW Morning Becomes Eclectic DJs named it a record of the month, and on September 24 guest DJ Laurie Anderson played the unreleased "Murder of Lawyers" on the air, profanity and all. That same week a fan who asked about taping got a two-line answer by email from Doughty: "Yes, we are pro-taping, but we've come to find that many venues, bafflingly, prohibit it even if the band doesn't mind. But you certainly have our approval."13

The reaction split the room. One regular posted "EL OSO? NO!" ("Bland, lifeless and garbled"), others answered that it was the tightest the rhythm section had ever sounded on record, and a long thread compared the sleeve's black silhouettes to Devo. Fans reported it playing in bars where the older records had gotten no reaction, with people dancing to "St. Louise Is Listening." One poster passed along that the band had recorded close to 21 songs for it, including "16 Horses" and one called "These Are the Reasons." On MuchMusic on October 11, when Sook-Yin Lee asked what "El Oso" meant, the band told her it was Spanish for "the oso." Fans said the title came from the bears the band drew on their set lists. By the end of October a Minneapolis regular noted the album sitting at No. 95 on the Billboard chart, weeks after its No. 49 debut, and that the "Circles" video had just been shot.1

The El Oso Tour, as Fans Saw It

The newsgroup was at its busiest during the El Oso tour, and its posts fill in what the gigography only lists. The fall 1998 headline shows projected old cartoons during the new songs; one Chicago fan agreed with a sour Sun-Times review that the visuals were doing work the older songs never needed. A fan at Irving Plaza on October 22, 1998 posted the set from memory, a near greatest-hits run that opened with "Screenwriter's Blues" and "Blueeyed Devil," put "Circles" in the middle with the intro "and now, our feature presentation," and closed with "Rolling" and "Super Bon Bon." The October 25 show at the 9:30 Club in Washington DC was webcast live and broadcast days later on WHFS, and a DJ there told a fan that Doughty considered it the band's best performance to date and that the band hoped to release it to a fan club. That never happened, but the tape circulated widely.1413

A yellow and green shield-shaped pin with the letters SC, the name Schulman across the top and a ribbon reading Ranger below
A Ranger pin from the El Oso promotion. The label made them, each with the recipient's last name, for the street team that helped promote the record, Opus Moreschi and Mat among them.

Fan set lists from the first weeks of the tour show how the shows were built. Chicago on October 10 ran about 90 minutes and mixed all three albums, with "Is Chicago, Is Not Chicago" segued into "The Incumbent" and an encore of "True Dreams of Wichita," "Mr. Bitterness," "Rolling" and "Super Bon Bon." At the Cleveland Agora on October 15, the band played 22 songs, came back for a second encore of "Janine," and Doughty ran his bits: the "Oh, Poppy!" call-and-response, a Spanish "¿Qué pasa con las mujeres? Yo no sé" leading into "I Miss the Girl," and introducing degli Antoni as "America's favorite teenager." At Higher Ground in Winooski, Vermont on October 18, with Los Amigos Invisibles opening, the band slid a bit of Madonna's "Like a Prayer" into "Is Chicago," Doughty held forth in Spanish, and the night's issue for discussion was marriage, a subject he said he couldn't be funny about. A fan who arrived early heard degli Antoni, Steinberg and Gabay soundchecking "Misinformed" without Doughty.

The 9:30 Club show on October 25 got the longest review in the group's history. The stage plot put Gabay's riser at stage left, degli Antoni's in the middle and Steinberg's upright at stage right, with Doughty, a self-proclaimed "Geek of the Week," front and center. "Screenwriter's Blues" opened slow and sedate until Gabay kicked into a jungle beat for the "you are listening" outro, "Collapse" had been rearranged with a jungle feel, and the whole room sang the Chris Rock line in "$300" while degli Antoni manipulated the sample further.

Boston's Avalon on October 20 was broadcast on WBCN and had its own rituals. Between songs the audience chanted "I AM YUVAL GABAY!", the band staged an interlude involving a demolished Teletubby doll, and during "Super Bon Bon" the crowd answered with "candy bar" and "forest fire." The Washington DC radio broadcast of the 9:30 Club show five days later cut five songs for time, from "Bus to Beelzebub" through "Mr. Bitterness," but kept "Janine." A fan who later burned copies of the full show for the newsgroup gave it the review the band would have wanted: "This is far better than any show I was privy to."13

A man in glasses and a dark suit playing a green guitar at a microphone under orange stage lights, with a keyboard player behind him and an upright bassist at right
Playing "Circles" on Late Show with David Letterman, November 4, 1998.

On Late Show with David Letterman on November 4, 1998, they played "Circles" without being made to trim it for time; viewers noticed degli Antoni's sampler loud in the mix, Gabay popping out from behind the kit to shake Letterman's hand, and Doughty dropping words out of the last choruses. In Amsterdam that month, a second encore that the crew was already tearing down for became a drum and bass version of "How Many Cans?" Fans also found an easter egg in the packaging: the white dots inside the El Oso booklet trace the bottom edges of the letters in "Soul Coughing" from the cover, with the logos and copyright line standing in for missing letters.

The 1999 Sno-Core tour put them in arenas with Everclear, a mismatch fans enjoyed describing. At the Aragon, a fan watched Doughty sit by the backstage wall with a Heineken during the headliner's set, bobbing his head in what looked like open mockery. Smaller moments mattered too: a soundcheck set for about 30 fans in Detroit before the State Theatre show, pudding cups thrown from the stage in Indianapolis and signed afterward by Steinberg, and, on his own message board in 1999, Doughty mentioning that he had quit smoking in January 1998 after working up to three packs a day.

The radio holiday shows that December put them on very mixed bills. At WHFS's HFSmas at the Patriot Center they shared the night with Everlast, Cake, Garbage and Hole and played almost all El Oso, keeping only "Bus to Beelzebub," "Is Chicago" and "Super Bon Bon" from the older records. At Minneapolis's Zone for the Holidays show at the Target Center, with Beck, the Goo Goo Dolls, Semisonic and Garbage, a fan sent her homemade El Oso bear mask backstage through a security guard, and during the last song a small boy appeared on stage wearing it and dancing; afterward fans lined up for his autograph.

Four men posing in front of a green roll-down shutter backstage, the second from the left in a red knit cap, red shirt and sunglasses holding a candy cane
Isaac Hayes backstage at WHFS's Holiday Nutcracker with Doughty, Gabay and degli Antoni. From Rolling Stone's Random Notes, January 21, 1999.

The HFSmas night had a better backstage story. Rolling Stone's Random Notes column (January 21, 1999) reported that the show was "practically an I Like Ike rally," because the MC was Isaac Hayes, and Soul Coughing and Cake shook with glee on meeting him. Doughty's verdict: "That's it, we're done. We might as well become plumbers." Steinberg entertained the other acts with an impromptu jam backstage, then asked Hayes to sign his upright bass. "That's going to be the only autograph on there," he gushed. The column ran a photo of Hayes with Doughty, Gabay and degli Antoni.15

Before the tour, on M2 in January 1999, Gabay joked that Sno-Core was supposed to follow places with snow, though a planned Alaska date had fallen through. On Sno-Core, Soul Coughing got about an hour and ten songs a night, with El Oso cartoons on the arena screens while the other acts just showed themselves on camera. In Las Vegas at the Hard Rock in February 1999 they opened with "Bus to Beelzebub," Doughty jumped into the crowd to sing to the front row, and he ended the night chanting "Candybar! Candybar!", which newsgroup regulars took as a nod to their own nickname for the group. In Pittsburgh in March they opened with "Circles" and ran "Rolling," "Blame," "I Miss the Girl," "St. Louise Is Listening," "$300," "Moon Sammy," "Mr. Bitterness," "Super Bon Bon" and "The Idiot Kings" to a teenage Everclear crowd.13

The college run that spring was looser. At Eau Claire, Wisconsin on May 14, 1999, fans counted a set that included "16 Horses," a "Woolly Imbibe" interlude after "The Idiot Kings," and a medley folding "Blueeyed Devil" into "Misinformed," "Monster Man" and "Houston," with "Uh, Zoom Zip" in the encore; Doughty wandered through the crowd during "Super Bon Bon," and for once there was no mosh lecture because there was no mosh. At the 9:30 Club on August 11, with Baltimore's Lake Trout opening, fans noted Steinberg's new electric bass on several songs, Doughty's new haircut, the return of his green Fender Coronado ("finally back from the guitar surgeon"), the old spoken intro to "White Girl" ("one for John Stamos, two for the nameless"), a "pow, how ya like me now" line from "212" dropped into "Blueeyed Devil," and a rare live "So Far I Have Not Found the Science."

Poster for Morphine and Soul Coughing at the Greek Theatre, Berkeley, Saturday July 24
The Greek Theatre in Berkeley, July 24, 1999, with Morphine. One of the canceled dates.

The summer of 1999 brought a loss. On July 6 the band canceled its July 21 to 27 dates, which were to have included Morphine, after Mark Sandman died onstage in Italy on July 3. Steinberg, a longtime friend, said in the statement that the loss was "tremendous both to the world of bass, song, and music" and that his only solace was that Sandman "died doing what he loved most." That June, fans had also spotted Steinberg filling in on bass for Beth Orton at short notice, an early sign of where he was headed. In August, at the 9:30 Club, degli Antoni said he was furious about bootleg "rarities" CDs being sold on eBay, and warned that if it kept up the band might stop letting fans tape shows. It was their last full year on the road.

Two photos shot from above the stage at the 9:30 Club. On the left, a guitarist, an upright bassist and a keyboard player amid road cases. On the right, a drummer in a white cap at a kit with Sabian cymbals
Two views from the 9:30 Club in Washington DC, August 11, 1999.

By the end of 1999 El Oso had done its job. It put them on arena stages, late-night TV and radio holiday bills, and degli Antoni was calling one of those August nights at the 9:30 Club the best recent show the band had played. It would also be the last studio album they made.


  1. Billboard. ↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎

  2. Gil Kaufman, "Soul Coughing Cut Loose In Studio For New LP," SonicNet, September 30, 1998. ↩︎↩︎

  3. Phil Johnson, "Soul Coughing: Fleece and Firkin, Bristol," The Independent, July 18, 1997, p. 9. ↩︎

  4. Robin Tolleson, "Rock Perspectives: Drum 'n' Bass - The New Frontier?," Modern Drummer, January 2000, pp. 150 to 156. ↩︎

  5. M. Doughty, "The Making of El Oso," AOL music board, December 1, 1997. ↩︎

  6. Lisa Verrico, "Diamond Wheezers," Vox, July 1997, p. 76. ↩︎

  7. Soul Coughing FAQ, version 2.0, SCUG, May 2000. ↩︎

  8. Still Rolling: The Soul Coughing Archive (@osoarchive), on X. ↩︎

  9. Caroline Sullivan, "Pop CD of the Week" capsule on El Oso, The Guardian, October 9, 1998, p. 34. ↩︎

  10. Mark Jenkins, El Oso and Los Amigos Invisibles preview, The Washington Post, October 23, 1998, p. N21. ↩︎

  11. Entertainment Weekly. ↩︎

  12. Spin. ↩︎

  13. alt.music.soulcoughing newsgroup, 1996 to 2013, via UsenetArchives.com. ↩︎↩︎↩︎↩︎

  14. Chicago Sun-Times. ↩︎

  15. Rolling Stone. ↩︎

Search

Every show, song, record and chapter. Try a venue, a city, a song, a year, a name or your zodiac sign.